Health Sharing Ministries: How They Work and the Risks
A health sharing ministry is not insurance. Members pay a monthly amount that goes toward other members’ medical bills, and they hope the group will help with theirs. But no law or contract makes the ministry or its members pay your bills. If they don’t, you are still responsible for them.
That doesn’t make every ministry a scam. But it does mean you should understand exactly what you’re giving up before you trade real coverage for a lower monthly price.
How health sharing works
The Texas Department of Insurance describes health care sharing ministries as groups that limit membership to people of a similar faith. It calls them a non-insurance arrangement in which members make monthly payments to cover other members’ medical expenses.
Each ministry has its own written guidelines. Those guidelines, and the ministry’s religious tenets, decide which bills can be shared. That is why every regulator we checked tells you to read them closely before you join.
What one state requires them to tell you
Nebraska law requires health care sharing ministries to give consumers a written notice. The Nebraska Department of Insurance published the required wording, which says:
This organization is not an insurance company, and its product should never be considered insurance. If you join this organization instead of purchasing health insurance, you will be considered uninsured. By the terms of this agreement, whether anyone chooses to assist you with your medical bills as a participant of this organization will be totally voluntary, and neither the organization nor any participant can be compelled by law to contribute toward your medical bills. Regardless of whether you receive payment for medical expenses or whether this organization continues to operate, you are always personally responsible for the payment of your own medical bills. This organization is not regulated by the Nebraska Department of Insurance. You should review this organization’s guidelines carefully to be sure you understand any limitations that may affect your personal medical and financial needs.
That notice is the clearest summary of the risks we’ve found. Read it twice.
The main risks
1. There’s no guarantee your bills get paid
This is the core difference from insurance. The Texas Department of Insurance says that if a ministry doesn’t pay a member’s claim, the member has no legal protection. Nebraska’s required notice says any help with your bills is totally voluntary.
2. Pre-existing conditions are often limited or excluded
Texas says these ministries often exclude pre-existing conditions. Nebraska warns that you may face pre-existing condition restrictions, and that the ministry’s religious tenets could disqualify you from having a bill shared.
Compare that with a Marketplace plan. HealthCare.gov says no insurance plan can reject you, charge you more, or refuse to pay for essential health benefits because of a condition you had before your coverage started.
3. Regulators usually can’t help you
Texas says health care sharing ministries are exempt from state and federal insurance regulation, except state balance billing laws. So its Department of Insurance usually can’t help if you have a complaint. Nebraska says the same: its department cannot assist with complaints about a ministry.
4. Doctors don’t have to honor a “discount” card
Nebraska’s Department of Insurance says it has seen consumers show providers a card from a sharing ministry that claims to give a discount. If the provider has no contract with the ministry, it doesn’t have to accept the discount. In some cases, members were left owing significant bills.
5. Some groups aren’t what they claim to be
Some organizations market themselves as health sharing ministries without meeting the legal definition. In December 2025, Washington’s Insurance Commissioner fined one such group $350,000. The office found that it had collected $524,095 from 376 Washington members but paid only $54,201 toward medical bills. It had also sold plans with pre-existing condition exclusions. Under Washington law, a legitimate ministry must have been sharing medical expenses continuously since December 31, 1999. This group was formed in 2022.
Texas also notes that some ministries spend a high percentage of member contributions on administrative expenses, and that the state has taken enforcement action against some of them.
Health sharing vs. a Marketplace plan
| Health sharing ministry | Marketplace plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Is it insurance? | No | Yes |
| Must it pay covered claims? | No. Sharing is voluntary | Yes |
| Pre-existing conditions | Often excluded or limited | Covered from the start |
| Essential health benefits (such as prescriptions, maternity and mental health care) | Not required | Required |
| Income-based savings | None | Available if your income is in range |
Other things to know
No federal tax penalty. The IRS says the federal penalty for not having coverage was reduced to zero starting with tax year 2019. So joining a ministry doesn’t trigger a federal penalty, but neither does being uninsured. Check whether your state has its own coverage requirement.
Getting back into a Marketplace plan. Outside Open Enrollment, you generally need a Special Enrollment Period to join a Marketplace plan. One of them follows the loss of qualifying health coverage. Since Nebraska’s notice says ministry members are considered uninsured, don’t count on leaving a ministry to open that window. Check with HealthCare.gov before you drop real coverage. For 2027 coverage in HealthCare.gov states, Open Enrollment runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027. See our Open Enrollment 2027 dates.
If you’re still considering it: questions to ask first
- Get the guidelines in writing and read the sections on what isn’t shared.
- How are pre-existing conditions handled? Is there a waiting period, or a lifetime exclusion?
- Is there a cap on how much will be shared for one condition, one year or a lifetime?
- How long has the organization been sharing bills? Does it meet your state’s legal definition?
- What share of member money goes to administration? Ask for its financial statements.
- Do your doctors and hospital know the ministry? Remember that a discount card doesn’t bind a provider with no contract.
- What happens if a bill isn’t shared? Assume you’d pay it yourself.
- Check with your state insurance department for any warnings or enforcement actions.
Before you choose sharing to save money
If you’re looking at health sharing because your premiums went up, pause first. Before you give up real coverage, make sure you’ve checked the options that still come with protections:
- You may still qualify for income-based savings, even after the extra federal help ended. See Lost your subsidy? Your options for 2027.
- A Bronze plan paired with an HSA is real insurance, and it now comes with an HSA’s tax breaks. See Bronze plans are now HSA-eligible.
- If you just lost a job, read COBRA vs. the Marketplace before you decide.
What to do next
Our Coverage Options Finder shows the options that fit your household, including the ones that come with consumer protections. For more on alternatives, see our Alternatives section.
Sources
- Health Care Sharing Ministries: Information You Should Know — Nebraska Department of Insurance
- Shopping for other ways to get a health plan? Choose wisely — Texas Department of Insurance
- Kuderer fines illegal health insurer $350,000 — Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner
- Marketplace health plans cover pre-existing conditions — HealthCare.gov
- What Marketplace health insurance plans cover — HealthCare.gov
- Special Enrollment Period — HealthCare.gov
- Federal poverty level (FPL) — HealthCare.gov
- Questions and answers on the individual shared responsibility provision — IRS
- Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance — HealthCare.gov