Health sharing vs. health insurance: what happens to a medical bill in each
A health sharing ministry is not insurance. That sentence matters most at one moment: when a medical bill arrives. Below, we follow the same bill through a health insurance plan and through a health sharing ministry, step by step.
The bill under health insurance
1. The provider sends a claim to your plan. Your doctor or hospital bills your insurance plan for the care you received.
2. The plan applies its contract. Your policy sets what’s covered and how much the plan pays. CMS explains that the plan works out an allowed amount for the service, pays its share, and leaves you a patient balance.
3. You get an explanation of benefits. CMS says this statement shows the total charges, what the plan paid and what you owe. It isn’t a bill. Your bill from the provider shouldn’t be higher than the patient balance it shows.
4. If the plan says no, it has to explain. HealthCare.gov says insurers have to tell you why they’ve denied a claim and how to dispute it.
5. You can appeal, and then go outside the company. There are two steps: an internal appeal, where you ask the insurer to review its own decision, and external review, where an independent third party decides. HealthCare.gov says that with external review, the insurance company no longer has the final say.
One more protection: for Marketplace plans, HealthCare.gov says no insurance plan can reject you, charge you more, or refuse to pay for essential health benefits because of a condition you had before your coverage started.
The same bill with a health sharing ministry
1. Members pay monthly share amounts. The Texas Department of Insurance describes health care sharing ministries as a non-insurance arrangement in which members make monthly payments to pay for other members’ medical expenses.
2. You submit the bill to the ministry. Each ministry has its own written guidelines, and those guidelines decide how you submit a bill and which bills can be shared. Nebraska’s Department of Insurance warns that a ministry’s religious tenets can also disqualify a bill from being shared.
3. The ministry decides whether the bill is shared. Here is the key difference. Nebraska’s required notice for ministries says help with your bills is totally voluntary, and that neither the organization nor any participant can be compelled by law to contribute.
4. If the bill isn’t shared, you pay it. The same notice says you are always personally responsible for your own medical bills, whether or not anyone helps. Texas says that if a ministry doesn’t pay, the member has no legal protection.
5. Regulators usually can’t step in. Texas says these arrangements are exempt from regulation, so its insurance department usually can’t help with a complaint. Nebraska’s notice says the ministry is not regulated by its Department of Insurance. Because insurance rules don’t apply, the internal-appeal and external-review rights described above don’t apply either.
Watch the condition limits too. Texas says ministries often exclude pre-existing conditions. And a provider with no contract with a ministry doesn’t have to accept a discount card it shows, Nebraska warns, which has left some members owing significant bills.
Side by side
| Step | Health insurance | Health sharing ministry (not insurance) |
|---|---|---|
| What you pay each month | A premium for a contract | A monthly share amount toward other members’ bills |
| What decides if a bill is paid | The policy’s terms | The ministry’s guidelines |
| Must the bill be paid? | Covered claims, yes | No. Sharing is voluntary |
| If the answer is no | Written reason, internal appeal, external review | The ministry’s own process under its guidelines; no legal right to external review |
| Who can help | Your state insurance department; for self-funded job-based plans, the U.S. Department of Labor | Usually no insurance regulator |
| Pre-existing conditions | Marketplace plans can’t refuse to pay for essential health benefits because of them | Often excluded |
Before you choose
If you’re weighing a ministry because it looks cheaper, read its guidelines in full and assume any bill that isn’t shared will be yours. Our guide to how health sharing ministries work and their risks covers the questions to ask first. It’s also worth checking whether you qualify for financial help with a Marketplace plan before you give up the protections above.
See which coverage options fit you
Answer five quick questions about your age, household and income. Free, and no contact details needed to see your results.
Sources
- Shopping for other ways to get a health plan? Choose wisely — Texas Department of Insurance
- Health Care Sharing Ministries: Information You Should Know — Nebraska Department of Insurance
- How to appeal an insurance company decision — HealthCare.gov
- External review — HealthCare.gov
- Who can help me with my health plan? — Texas Department of Insurance
- Marketplace health plans cover pre-existing conditions — HealthCare.gov
- How to read a health insurance explanation of benefits — Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services